ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT > CURTAIN CALL

Saying Yes to ‘Prog-Rock’

By David J. Spatz
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 15 | Posted Feb. 11, 2010

Chris Squire isn’t getting his hopes up just yet. But the only original member still working with the 1960s rock band Yes admits it’s probably just a matter of time before his long-running group is finally voted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

The hall’s perceived bias against progressive rock bands will ease somewhat later this year when the band Genesis is inducted into the ranks of legendary artists who left their imprint on the musical landscape.

“People used to ask me why we’re not in [the hall of fame], and I’d remind them that neither is Genesis, neither is Jethro Tull, neither is Emerson, Lake & Palmer,” Squire says. “It turns out there’s a whole block of prog-rock bands that have been ignored.”

Not that the hall of fame would ever admit it, but Squire says the rumor that’s circulated for years is that hall co-founder Jann Wenner, the publisher of Rolling Stone magazine, isn’t a fan of progressive rock, hence the slight.

“But the good news is that they’re putting Genesis in this year, so there might be hope for us,” Squire adds, with one tiny caveat. “Even though it should be the other way around.”

If album and concert ticket sales were the only criteria used to pick new inductees to the hall, then Yes would have earned its place years ago.

The band has sold tens of millions of copies of the 19 studio albums, nine live recordings, 15 compilation albums and 32 singles since Yes was formed in England more than 42 years ago. Its 1971 album Fragile, which contained the monster hit single “Roundabout,” was the first of the band’s seven platinum recordings.

And when it came to touring in the mid-1970s, Yes was among the small handful of artists who could fill 100,000-seat stadiums.

If the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame decides to induct Yes, one of the dilemmas will be choosing which members get in. Squire, who’s been playing bass with the group since it was formed in 1968, says there’s been a revolving door of members over the past four decades.

“Some guys left to do [solo] projects or work with other bands and some left and came back,” he says during a phone call from his Arizona home. “I guess maybe they’ll just have to induct everyone, even the new guys.”

Unlike other bands that have seen members come and go over the years, Yes seemed to benefit from the turnover of musicians, says Squire, who will lead his band onto the stage of the Tropicana on Friday, Feb. 12.

“I’d rather think the reason why Yes has been around so long is that we have, from time to time, had personnel changes,” he explains. “The incoming new members brought in new ideas and so it kind of refreshed the whole, and the whole sound.”

Which is probably very important to a band that was literally making up progressive rock — or art-rock, as it was also called — as they went along.

Progressive rock, as invented by Yes, tended to blend symphonic sounds with traditional rock elements. Songs were longer than typical rock tunes, and the lyrics to the songs were often abstract.

Because prog-rock also relied on protracted instrumentals that often showcased a musician’s talent, it’s no surprise that many members of Yes left the band to pursue solo careers. Although Squire was renowned for his melodic-like approach to playing bass guitar, he’s only released one solo album, Fish Out of Water, in 1975.

Squire has never performed any of that solo work live, but he’s hoping that will change later this year when he tours with former Genesis guitarist Steve Hackett, with whom he collaborated on a new album.

“I’ve worked with a lot of people during my career, but I guess I always kept my concentration on Yes, which is probably why I only did the one solo album,” he says.

Squire is often amazed at the longevity of Yes and the loyalty of its fans. When he started the band, he had no clue they’d still be working four decades later.

“When the Beatles broke up, I remember thinking, ‘Boy, they had six years, it would be great if Yes could have a six-year career,’ ” he says with a laugh.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend

COMMENTS

Comments 1 - 15 of 15
Report Violation

1. Vin said... on Feb 13, 2010 at 11:50AM

“check out this interview..sold lots of records...”

Report Violation

2. rich said... on Feb 20, 2010 at 06:59PM

“Glad that Yes chose to play in Atlantic City, they are a great bunch of musicians.”

Report Violation

3. Andrés R. said... on Mar 6, 2010 at 12:42PM

“Music Masters...amazing Yes.”

Report Violation

4. Rodeo Skunk said... on Mar 26, 2010 at 12:26PM

“The critics never liked Genesis, Yes or ELP. They felt they were too pretentious. Even the article above describes their lyrics as abstract. Too me they are not abstract you just have to read them and understand them, like any good book. Most critics preferered acts like Springsteen, Dylan, Neil Young with their three chords and the truth.”

Report Violation

5. 12-String Frank said... on Apr 9, 2010 at 01:59PM

“Chris Squire has a point that perhaps they can't get into the hall of fame (shame) is due to their having 18 members over the years.

If they did get in, the Hall should give Banks and Howe an award, but what about Rabin? Both White and Bruford have to get it. Both Wakeman and Kaye must get it, but what about Downes or Igor K.?

When Genesis got it, I didn't see Anthony Phillips at the induction ceremony.”

Report Violation

6. fishrobber said... on Apr 10, 2010 at 06:55PM

“Frank: spot on. Where does one stop the revolving door? If you are electing "prog rock Yes", do you snub the more popular songs from the 80's, and therefore those members (Kaye, Horn, Rabin)? Yes returned to a more prog sound in the 90s-00s, but added Sherwood and Igor. Maybe just let Yes decide who is honored .. I'm sure they can all agree on that (yeah, right!!)”

Report Violation

7. DEn said... on Apr 13, 2010 at 09:44AM

“Félicitations roulette en ligne! Excellent travail!
Bonne chance!”

Report Violation

8. Stereosage said... on Apr 28, 2010 at 01:32PM

“Hey, they've been around for many times longer than The Beatles. They have written and played a lot of great music. But, basically, American critics think progressive rock goes against the simple, American roots of 'rock and roll.'”

Report Violation

9. choudhary said... on May 13, 2010 at 07:16PM

“Far how long have they been there? predators of crabs |sea weed extract |brown sea weed... Music is not really good. Its Prohibited in Islam as to it creates hypocrisy in ones heart”

Report Violation

10. Jeff_Rotull said... on May 20, 2010 at 08:35PM

“Skunk, sorry, but I'll bet even Jon would describe his lyrics as abstract; he has said that he often chooses words based more on their sound and sonic relationship to the music than meaning.

As for revolving lineups and who gets in, I think Tull would present even more of a problem, as at least 25 people have "passed through this family we call Jethro Tull" as Ian once put it. Or who knows, maybe less of a dilemma - maybe it should just be Ian and Martin.”

Report Violation

11. Akif said... on Jul 12, 2010 at 10:37AM

“I agree with farhaj. It really creates Hypocrispy in ones heart!!

12. Carl said... on Jul 24, 2010 at 03:42PM

“Interesting article. Very useful. Thank you.
Qbasic

Report Violation

13. jane said... on Aug 22, 2010 at 09:07PM

“How does it vreate hypocrisy in one's heart? I think you are commenting on the wrong site, my friend. Yes forever!
larissa riquelme paraguay

Report Violation

14. Information about caves said... on Sep 1, 2010 at 02:17PM

“Hey, they've been around for many times longer than The Beatles. They have written and played a lot of great music. But, basically, American critics think progressive rock goes against the simple, American roots of 'rock and roll.

Information about caves | Amazing Pictures

Report Violation

15. Information about caves said... on Sep 1, 2010 at 02:20PM

“Go and find a good psychologist and ask hum a question. How does the music effect your inner hearts feeling?

Information about caves | Amazing Pictures

ADD COMMENT

Rate:
(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Yes: Still Prog After All These Years
By Ray Schweibert

Alan White: “We’ve also got a lot of stalwart fans who I’m sure include people who have seen Yes shows 50 or 60 times. I had a guy come up to me at the start of this tour and tell me ‘This is my 80th show.’ I thought, oh my God, you’ve got to get a life, guy.”

RELATED: Jon Anderson to Release New Song 'Open' Oct. 25, Plays Trop Saturday Yes Indeed


 


ACW EVENT SERIES