Baseball, 'Boardwalk Empire' and Arnold Rothstein

With Boardwalk Empire and Major League Baseball's seasons over, a look at the infamous Black Sox scandal and Arnold Rothstein's part in the big fix.

By Jim Waltzer
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 0 | Posted Dec. 12, 2011

Share this Story:

Meanwhile, another potential fixer emerged from the ranks: former big-league pitcher “Sleepy” Bill Burns, a man with a mediocre fastball, but an endearing drawl and, more importantly, a buddy of fellow hurler Cicotte’s. For Burns, Gandil upped the ante to $100,000. Burns scouted for cash, but all roads on the money trail led to Arnold Rothstein.

So now, writes author Asinof, “two rival factions were working the same street.”

Rothstein already had taken sufficient measures to secure the fix, but Burns could provide an insurance policy — with no premium payment. Rothstein stocked another member of his entourage, former featherweight boxing champion Abe Attell, with betting money (to be wagered on the National League champion Cincinnati Redlegs, of course) and made the “Little Champ” his emissary to Burns. (Asinof and Pietrusza disagree as to whether Rothstein called the shots in this instance or Attell acted on his own — either way, the intent was to lead Burns on and then stiff him.)

The Sox did tank the Series (after pitcher Cicotte signaled thumbs-up by beaning the Reds’ leadoff hitter in Game One), five games to three (in a best-of-nine Series), though money betrayals and conscience spurred them to play on the level in their three victories. A disgruntled Burns became the prosecution’s star witness in the subsequent beleaguered trial beginning in Illinois State Court in July 1921, but despite his convincing testimony and confessions from three of the Sox conspirators, all of the players and gamblers were exonerated. (The signed confessions had somehow become “unavailable.”)

Regular viewers of the HBO series Boardwalk Empire have seen the character of Arnold Rothstein request that Nucky Thompson, in a quid pro quo, influence the Illinois judge to let him off, but it was Rothstein’s crafty powerful attorney, payoffs to witnesses, and American League President Ban Johnson’s self-interest that, ultimately, kept the Big Bankroll rolling. He was never even indicted. 

When the verdict was handed down, the courtroom erupted as if the White Sox had just won theWorld Series, but the jubilation was short-lived. The next day, newly appointed baseball commissioner Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis banned the Gang of Eight from baseball.
For life.

Skating free per usual, Arnold Rothstein had more fortunes to make. And a rendezvous with a bullet in seven years’ time.

Click here for Atlantic City Weekly's Boardwalk Empire Notes page

Click here to see video from the Boardwalk Empire Season One Premiere Party in Atlantic City

Click here to see video from the Boardwalk Empire Season Two Premiere Party in Atlantic City

Click here to see photos from Season One Premiere Party in Atlantic City

Click here to see photos from Season Two Premiere Party in Atlantic City

Prev| Page: 1 2
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend



(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Life After Jimmy
By Daniel Aupperle

"The ending caught me by surprise even though I know the history to which it's adhering. I thought it was such a bold and dramatic move. You sort of figured the series was going to be about these two characters and then one of them dies suddenly at the end of season two."

RELATED: Kovacs’ Knack Ken Burns on 'Prohibition' and 'Boardwalk Empire' Complete First Season of 'Boardwalk Empire' on DVD Boardwalk Empire Season 3 Updates Vince Giordano on 'Boardwalk Empire' Soundtrack Grammy Win Stephen DeRosa: Eddie Cantor in 'Boardwalk Empire' How 'Boardwalk Empire' Found Nelson Johnson Top 12 '5 Questions With ...' Interviews of 2011 5 Questions with TV Critic David Bianculli on Boardwalk Empire's Second Season

Related Content

A Grammy for Atlantic City: 'Boardwalk Empire' Soundtrack Wins Grammy
By Jeff Schwachter 

“It’s been my love and passion ever since I was five years old and I think this music moves people. People who come to see us, they say, ‘When I got here I was in kind of a blah mood, not so good, or depressed, or whatever and I come out in just a whole different place. I’m laughing, my spirits are lifted, it’s cheaper than going to a psychiatrist!’”

RELATED: Coasting: Manuel Talkin’ 
Baseball at Trop
 ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Is Back
 for Season 4 Diana Krall Brings ‘Doll’
 to Borgata Beth Tinnon: 'A Night at the Speakeasy' Truth and Soul, Boardwalk Empire and a Short White Mule ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Season Three Preview
 Terry Winter Interview: 'Boardwalk Empire' Season 3 Local History: 'Boardwalk Empire' Atlantic City Ballet Roars with ‘Swing’ and 'Sins' for 30th Anniversary Mentoring Atlantic City’s Impressionable Youth
 Vince Giordano: The Man Behind the Music of 'Boardwalk Empire' The Sophie Tucker of 'Boardwalk Empire' Boardwalk Empire’s Agent Sebso Stars in New Rap Video
 Paz de la Huerta: Nucky's (Show) Girl on 'Boardwalk Empire' Embracing ‘Boardwalk Empire’ ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Soundtrack 
 Laciura’s Living the Life, ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Style Buscemi, Boardwalk Empire Win Again The Sounds of ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Leon Redbone Returns
 to Stockton

Related Content

Atlantic City History: Conversations & Storytelling — Entertainment & Nightlife, Pt. One (Episode Six)
By Jeff Schwachter

In the sixth episode of this multi-part series, the distinguished panel of Atlantic City historians and authors begin to discuss the history of entertainment and nightlife in the resort, which has played such a vital role in Atlantic City for more than a century.

RELATED: Life in the Laugh Lane United Nations, Modern Economy Has Roots in Atlantic City Songs About Atlantic City

Related Content

The Original Gangsters: Nucky, Capone, Luciano and 'Boardwalk Empire'
By Michael Pritchard

Early in the premiere episode of HBO’s Boardwalk Empire, a crowd of dapper Atlantic City movers and shakers, partying well into the night in a spiffy supper club, make a familiar countdown, cocktail glasses held high...

RELATED: 'Boardwalk Empire' Will End Its Run with Final Season This Fall 'Boardwalk Empire' Season 4 Snapshots Coasting: ‘Project Runway’ Comes to 
Hamilton Mall Exploring the 1920s in Atlantic City 'Boardwalk Empire' Set To Return in September on HBO Boardwalk Empire's Agent Sebso Stars in New Viral Video 2011 Holiday Gift Guide Interview with Comedian Steven Wright HBO Debuts 'Boardwalk Empire' Season 2 Trailer A Stroll Down the 
Atlantic City Boardwalk
. Part Two Battling Booze
 Song, Dance . . . Demeaning? Antique ‘Empire’ Hello Sunday, Hello 1920: 'Boardwalk Empire' Turns Back the Clock. Empire Builders: From Plexus to HBO ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Trivia Atlantic City Still Magical for Vicki Gold-Levi HBO's 'Boardwalk Empire' the Talk of Atlantic City Photos, Video and Observations from HBO's 'Boardwalk Empire' Premiere Party at Caesars Atlantic City 5 Questions With ... Vincent Piazza of 'Boardwalk Empire' 'Boardwalk Empire' Renewed for Another Season The Atlantic City Experience Atlantic City History: Conversations & Storytelling - The Boardwalk, Pt. 1 'Boardwalk Empire' Trivia! Wanted In Atlantic City HBO's 'Boardwalk Empire' Picks Up Golden Globe Nominations Atlantic City History - Conversations & Storytelling: The Boardwalk, Pt. 2 Alantic City History - Conversations & Storytelling: Success in Atlantic City, Pt. 1

Related Content

Boardwalk Empire Season 2 Premiere Weekend in Atlantic City
By Ken Koda

The famed seaside resort that is portrayed in HBO's hit drama series Boardwalk Empire celebrated the show's second season premiere on Sunday, Sept. 25, in a number of ways over the weekend.

RELATED: Local Historians at Atlantic City Library
 Saturday Ed Asner as FDR at Stockton
 T Fox Time at 25 Hours 
 ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Lucky Charms
 On the Set of ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Free Screening of Season 2 Premiere of 'Boardwalk Empire' at Caesars Atlantic City Sunday’s ‘Boardwalk Empire’ Premiere Party Nucky’s Right-Hand-Man: Anthony Laciura

Related Content

Scorsese's Valentine to Cinema

By Lori Hoffman

With the family film Hugo, Martin Scorsese, who is not only one of the world’s finest filmmakers but also a noted film historian and film preservationist, unleashes his devotion to the magic of movies with a zeal that is enchanting.

RELATED: Bob Dylan's Tribute to Martin Scorsese Scorsese’s ‘Shutter’ Sympathy for the Devil

Related Content

Terence Winter Is In the Season
 of His Contentment
By Jeff Schwachter

“The three eras that attracted me where the 1920s, the ‘50s and the ‘70s. And really HBO’s mandate was [so broad that] I literally had a huge canvass to work from.”

RELATED: An Educator’s Untimely End 5 Questions With ... Terence Winter