Fifth Dimension

The Chelsea hotel’s Dining on the Fifth has a new look, but it, and the more informal Teplitzky’s on the first floor, are still tops among dining destinations.

By Frank Gabriel
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 0 | Posted Mar. 12, 2014

Share this Story:

Since opening in July 2008 as Atlantic City’s first “boutique” non-casino property, The Chelsea hotel has also cultivated a serious culinary reputation for itself.

From that time through to the current regime of food-and-beverage director Megan McNulty and chef Jaime Quintana, the facility earned a solid niche amongst food folk in the highly competitive restaurant market that is Atlantic City.

We visited recently, to sample their repositioned Dining on the Fifth space — once steak house Chelsea Prime — and the ground-level, all-day gem Teplitzky’s.

Our evening on the Fifth began with an appetizer trio of mini crab cakes. Three perfectly formed, round nuggets of mostly lump crab nicely pan-browned and arranged on a wide plate dotted with orange aioli.

Cuban pork tacos, like the cakes, brought a portion of three. Soft mini tortillas overflowed with warm, mildly seasoned pork. A diced mango salsa accompanied, adding color and creating a nice compliment to the savory meat.

Both plates ably performed the most essential purpose of apps, igniting appetites in anticipation of what follows. Like our favorite item of this night, surprisingly, a chopped salad.

Despite depths of winter outside, this bowl was loaded with summery goodness; crisp romaine, corn, sliced red pepper and onion, tiny cuts of haricot verts and scads of creamy, luscious avocado. All would have been fine solo, with the avocado’s natural moisture as dressing, but the provided Green Goddess tossed throughout was an enchanting, herbaceous stroke of genius.

My entrée, pistachio crusted tuna with sautéed white beans, roasted peppers and lemon oil drizzle, arrived in seven thick slices, beautifully fanned across half of the plate. The remaining portion was ladled with a soft, aromatic blend of sautéed bean mixture drizzled with lemon oil. We greatly enjoyed the presentation and quality of fish, but felt a bit too much garlic undermined the pistachio’s delicate contribution.

My dining partner opted for another seafood, seared scallops over Arborio rice and asparagus. Four discs of creamy mollusks were presented atop risotto, dotted with the aristocratic green vegetable, a sure portent of spring’s imminent arrival.

Desserts brought a cookie trio; chocolate chip, oatmeal and sugar served warm in a cool, self-contained ramekin, a scoop of ice cream riding alongside.

My chocolate Kahlua cake, rich and dense, delivered potent, not-so-sweet notes defining the real nature of cacao, given an extra oomph via the lively coffee essence of that Mexican liqueur.

Throughout our meal, we couldn’t help but notice a distinct change in the overall personality evident at the establishment as well. What once was a retro supper club now pulses a younger, hipper vibe, with a clientele largely composed of sharp 20- to 40-somethings.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend



(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Sweetening the Deal
By Frank Gabriel

Each and every spring and summer season, the Borgata manages to develop, nurture and craft exciting new food concepts with which to tantalize local diners and regional visitors alike. This year will see Borgata kick off the summer dining season in a similar fashion with the anticipated grand opening of the Borgata Baking Company on Friday, May 23.

RELATED: Vagabond Vittles Burgers, Take a Bow!
 Ironclad Innovator: The Iron Room in Atlantic City Sushi by the Seashore
 Savor Stella

Related Content

Sushi Sure to Please
By Frank Gabriel

chef/author Anthony Bourdain admonished readers about hazards of eating seafood on Monday, saying “I never order fish on Monday, unless I’m eating at a four-star restaurant where I know they are buying their fish directly from the source. Azure, chef Alain Allegretti’s two-year-old, terminally pretty restaurant at Revel, turns that thinking on its pointy little head via the recent introduction of a “Sushi Monday” promotion.

RELATED: Continental, Souzai Special Events Sushi Shangri-la

Related Content

Art Deco Diner
By Frank Gabriel

Add another contender to the short list of our region's very best brunch spots, the new -- or should that read reincarnated? -- Teplitzky's Coffee Shop in midtown Atlantic City. Situated within a gl...

Related Content

Chelsea to Host Third Annual Big Teplitzky Challenge
By AC Weekly Staff

Plus, the Average Joe Expo, Diva Bingo Benefit and the Album of the Week

RELATED: Brunch Redefined
 Test Your Pipes at Teplitzky’s in Atlantic City The Big Teplitzky Fundraiser Out and About: Firefighter’s Never Forget

Related Content

Classic Nouvea at The Ebbitt Room
By Frank Gabriel

Housed in the historic, restored Virginia Hotel — itself dating to 1879 — the Ebbitt’s pretty space transforms via an array of lights and decorations into a holiday spectacle.

RELATED: Dining au Deux

Related Content

Gastronomic Gifts

By Frank Gabriel

If you’ve got an inveterate food fanatic on your holiday shopping list, someone who truly appreciates all things gastronomic, this column is for you.

RELATED: Food (Gifts) for Thought
 Jose Garces Truckin’ at Revel Wishful Eating
 Santa Shaq Visits Atlantic City Make a List, Check it Twice, Find that Perfect Gift for Half the Price
 Holiday Gift Guide 2012 Coasting - Tanger's Season of Giving; A.C.'s Holiday Parade 8 Ways to DO AC Free This Holiday Season

Related Content

Happy Hour Heaven
By Ray Schweibert

No longer a term merely designed to attract customers during slower times, some Atlantic City-area establishments 
have nearly become synonymous with their sensational Happy-hour offerings. 

RELATED: Spring Shopping Spree at Pier Shops at Caesars

Related Content

Let’s Do Brunch!

By Ray Schweibert

Several Atlantic City area establishments run special brunch menus during peak times of the week, and some even take things a step further by adding an element of entertainment to their brunch munchies. 

RELATED: Phillips: First Class Sea Fare 

Related Content

Chelsea’s Sizzlin’ Summer

By Ray Schweibert

In keeping with Atlantic 
City’s multi-cultural heritage, the Chelsea hotel is blending a variety of international influences into an extensive entertainment slate throughout the summer. 

RELATED: Bartender Tips: Ducktown Tavern’s 
Brian Ireland ‘Boardwalk’ Buzz 
 Midweek Mirth at Chelsea Art Blakey Tribute Wednesday at Chelsea Chelsea Stirs Up MatzoBall on Christmas Eve Super Supper Club at the Chelsea Euro Nights at the Chelsea Coasting: Chelsea Hosts Winter Jazz Series Chelsea All Night 24 Hours at the Chelsea

Related Content

Dishes, Dreams and Delicacies

By Frank Gabriel

You seemingly can’t throw a rock at a TV today without hitting a show dedicated to the terrors being foisted on the American south and Midwest by hoards of feral boar.

RELATED: Downbeach Duo
 Seasoned Greetings Merriment in Margate Waltz Through Time: Where the Fishing Flourished Girasole: Atlantic City’s Little Sunflower Fisch Kitchen: Seafood with a Side of Philosophy 

Related Content

Eating Their Way Across Town

With all due apologies to Charles Dickens, Atlantic City currently finds itself in a situation that is remarkably like “the best of times, the worst of times.” Even as we compete with neighboring states’ ever more aggressive bids to attract regional tourism with their new casinos, our city boasts a new draw of its own: There has simply never been a better local food scene than there is today.

RELATED: New Setting for Old Favorite Boutique Buffet